The RSS satellite global temperature for April 2018 shows a slight drop on March.
Compared to UAH satellite data, there has been slightly more movement in RSS data, with a range of around 0.1°C compared with UAH's 0.05°C, but overall the picture is very similar so far, with temperatures being slightly below the long term trend, but no sign of the big reversion seen after the 1998 El Niño.
Details
RSS has April 2018 at 0.45°C above the 1979-1998 base period, compared to 0.54°C for March.
This makes 2018 the 6th warmest April in the RSS data set.
The trend since 1979 is 1.93°C / century.
In contrast to the UAH satellite data, RSS is the fastest warming of all data sets over the satellite era.
Prediction
The prediction for 2018 shows a slight drop from last month.
My simple statistical analysis suggests 2018 will average 0.527 ± 0.118°C, compared with last month's prediction of 0.541 ± 0.136°C.
The average for the first 4 months is 0.506°C, so this will require warmer temperatures to develop later in the year.
As with other data sets this prediction is based mainly on the assumption that temperatures will tend towards the trend, not on any specific predictions of weather conditions.
On this basis, there is a good chance (~60%) that 2018 will be the 6th warmest on record.
There's a small chance (~7%) that it will finish below 6th, though if it does it could fall someway down the rankings.
There's a reasonable chance (~30%) that it could be 5th or better, though almost certainly not 1st.
RSS 4.0 Probabilities of Rankings for 2018
Rank
Year
Anomaly
Probability
Cumulative
1
2016
0.75
0.02%
0.02%
2
2017
0.64
3.11%
3.13%
3
2010
0.58
14.88%
18.01%
4
1998
0.58
0.21%
18.23%
5
2015
0.55
13.61%
31.83%
6
2005
0.43
61.93%
93.77%
7
2014
0.43
1.02%
94.79%
8
2003
0.39
3.95%
98.74%
Below 8th
n/a
n/a
1.26%
100.00%
Closing Thoughts
Both satellite data sets are predicting 2018 will probably be around 6th warmest, whereas surface data sets are tending towards 4th warmest.
The difference between the two is mostly to do with the satellite data showing 1998 and 2010 as being much warmer than in the surface sets.
In terms of recent history, all data sets are suggesting similar things, that the past 4 years have all been pretty hot, and this is very different to the previous El Niño peaks, that only lasted for a single year.
All this suggests we are not likely to see the return of the old Great Pause any time soon, and probably ever.
If warming did stop in 1997 it's certainly going again, and had no effect on the long term trend.
It's easy to predict what happens next, and this can be seen in many discussions I've had on WUWT.
1. The claim of a new pause, starting just before the latest El Niño. Last time we had to wait seven years before claims that there had been no warming since 1997, or even that there had been rapid cooling, but now I'm already seeing claims based on the last two years.
2. Some, such as Lord Monckton, will deny they ever thought the pause was important and will insist that the real point is that temperatures may not warm as much as expected, and that warming is a good thing.
Christopher Monckton of Brenchley is back at Watt's Up With That with the first of what promises to be a series of articles about IPCC projections.
The article is
Tamper, tamper! How They failed to hide the gulf between predicted and observed warming
.
In it he revisits his usual argument that the rate of warming in the slowest warming data set (UAH 6) does not match the rate of warming predicted in the oldest IPCC report from 1990.
He also says that all the data sets have been tampered with -
in the article he objects to the changes to RSS 4, but in the comments he also says that the tampering charge applies to all data sets including UAH 6.
The only reason for using that particular data set was that it was the first to be released, and not because it happens to be the coolest.
He uses the oldest IPCC projections, by definition the least reliable, from 1990 and the slowest warming data set (UAH 6) to claim that there has only been half as much warming as predicted.
As Fig. 1 shows, in the 39 years 1 month from December 1978 to December 2017, the planet has warmed by half a Celsius degree.
But that is equivalent to 1.28 C°/century, or little more than one-third of the 3.3 C°/century predicted with
substantial confidence by IPCC in 1990 and also by the fifth-generation general-circulation models of the
Climate Model Intercomparison Project in 2013.
This is wrong on most counts.
He quotes the 1990 IPCC report as saying with substantial confidence a rate of warming of 3.3°C / century.
This figure does not appear in the report, and the figure they do state (0.3°C / decade) is not described as having substantial confidence.
What the report says is they have ... substantial confidence that models can predict at least the broad scale features of climate change.
(My emphasis.)
He also claims the latest IPCC projections are the same as those from the 1990s, but this is also wrong.
His 3.3°C / century warming is somewhere between two of the IPCC scenarios, but only for long term warming, up to the end of the century.
In the short term it says all scenarios are similar and projects between 0.3 and 0.7°C warming between 1995 and 2025 (using 20 year averages).
Using Monckton's trick of converting all warming projections to linear trends this is a rate of warming of between 1°C / century and 2.3°C / century.
Even UAH 6 is within these bounds.
But, what interests me most is where Monckton gets his 3.3°C / century figure from, and why this is faster than what he was claiming they said only a couple of years ago.
Back in May 2016 Monckton introduced the Global Warming Speedometer.
(Never to be seen again).
In this he claimed the 1990 IPCC report predicted a rate of warming of 2.8°C / century, with a lower bound of 1.9°C / century.
What the 1990 IPCC Report Said
The main description of future warming is made in page xxii of the first IPCC report.
They say that temperatures are likely to raise at a rate of 0.3°C / decade.
They then give figures for the amount of warming both from the pre-industrial period and the present (ie 1990).
They define the pre-industrial period as 1750-1800 (page 22) or just 1765 (page 177).
They state that by the the end of the century temperatures will be 4°C warmer than the pre-industrial period, and 3°C warmer from present.
They also say this will mean that by 2025 global temperatures will be 2°C warmer than pre-industrial levels, and 1°C from present temperatures.
This is illustrated with this graph, showing the likely warming and the upper and lower bounds.
However they define the pre-industrail period, it's clear from their figures and the graph that they consider there has been 1°C of warming from pre-industrail to 1990.
What's not clear is how precise these figures are meant to be, all temperature increases are given to whole degrees.
The projected 1°C by 2025 would translate to an average warming rate of 2.8°C / century, and this appear to be how Monckton calculated the rate for his speedometer,
although he credits this to page xxiv.
This is interesting as that page suggests a slower rate of warming.
Page xxiv quotes a projection of 1.8°C above pre-industrial levels by 2030.
Obviously this is less than the 2°C by 2025 they give on page xxii.
Taking this with the supposed 1°C warming up to present would suggest a projected 0.8°C warming over the 40 years from 1990 to 2030;
a rate of 2°C / century, with low and high estimates of 1.4°C and 3.0°C / century.
This would mean most data sets are well within the projected warming rates, and UAH 6 is only slightly below the lower estimate.
So why does Monckton believe that page xxiv is actually claiming a warming rate of 3.3 °C / century?
In response to a question from DWR54 he says,
In reply to the furtively anonymous “DWR54” p. xxiv of IPCC (1990) says:
“The numbers given below are based on high-resolution models,
scaled to be consistent with our best estimate of global mean warming of 1.8 C by 2030
[compared with pre-industrial temperatures] …
the numbers below should be reduced by 30% for the low estimate or increased by 50% for the high estimate.”
There had been 0.45 K global warming in the industrial era, so IPCC was predicting 1.35 K of warming over 4.1 decades, equivalent to 3.3 K/century.
In the passages cited by “DWR54”, IPCC rounded this value to 3 K.
His entire argument is based on the claim that there had only been 0.45°C warming from the pre-industrial period by 1990,
and that the IPCC were predicting an additional 1.35°C warming by 2030.
This does not agree with anything they say elsewhere and does not agree with their graph.
Here (in red) is what Monckton's 1.35°C of warming looks like.
Monckton's 0.45°C figure probably comes from page 199 of the IPCC report.
This is a chapter on instrument measurements, in which they say that the world is probably 0.45 ± 0.15°C warmer than the late 19th century.
There are many problems with Monckton using this figure.
For a start it isn't for warming from the pre-industrial period, but from the late 19th century.
Then there's the way he ignores the large uncertainty in the stated figure.
But the big problem is that whatever the merits of the 0.45°C figure, it isn't the one the IPCC used when they stated the warming rates from the pre-industrial period on pages xxii and xxiv.
You cannot simply take an unrelated figure from a different part of the report,
use it to add an extra 0.55°C to the expected warming and claim that's what the IPCC really meant - with substantial confidence.
In short - Monckton has literally made up a figure, and then quoted it as if it was a direct figure from the IPCC.
Monckton's Own Predictions
In commenting on Monckton's article I couldn't resist pointing out one of his own predictions, made in front of a congressional hearing in 2009.
He claimed then that global temperatures might only rise by 0.5°F by the end of the century,
that is about 0.28°C.
This means that by Monckton's own logic, temperatures are warming more than 4 times faster than his prediction, even using the slowest rising UAH data.
When I mentioned this in the comments, Monckton said he couldn't remember making such a prediction
In reply to Bellman, I do not recollect having predicted in 2009 that global warming would be only 0.25 K/century.
I said that at that time the warming rate was equivalent to 0.25 K/century.
I have published a series of papers in which the best estimate of warming is around 1.2-1.3 K/century.
That warming rate, and no higher rate, is consistent with the officially estimated net anthropogenic forcings in the industrial era.
His exact words, both in written and spoken testimony to congress, were
This century we may warm the world by half a Fahrenheit degree, if that.
It's not clear why he thinks the warming rate at the time was 0.25°C / century.
At the time he was saying there had been rapid cooling (but that's another story).
Possibly he did make a mistake both in his written and spoken testimony - elsewhere in the speech he suggests warming may be as much as 2°F by the end of the century.
But it does follow another habit of stating predictions with no indication of doubt.
For example in 2015 he said:
No warming has yet arisen this century.
Warming may be 0.6 K by 2100, could be as low as 0.4° K and will not exceed 1° K.
Now he's saying the most likely warming rate is 1.2 - 1.3 °C / century.
Yet he wants to hold the IPCC to account for projections made almost 30 years ago.
I'm going to try to update some temperatures as they come in (No promises).
Dr Roy Spencer has announced the value for his UAH 6, and it's a rise, up to 0.41 °C, compared with the 1981 - 2010 base period.
This makes it the 3rd warmest August in the UAH 6 data set, only slightly cooler than August last year,
and 0.11 °C cooler than August in 1997.
To put this into some context this graph compares temperatures around the two major El Niños of 1997 and 2016.
What this shows is that whilst the El Niño spikes were very similar in terms of absolute temperature, the years preceding the 2016 El Niño were warmer than the years preceding that of 1998, and so far the year following 2016 has been warmer.
The Forecast
The increase in temperature has pushed the average temperature for 2017 to 0.32 °C, up from 0.30 °C in July.
The forecast reflects this with a rise from 0.30 ± 0.08 in July to 0.32 ± 0.06 °C.
Annual temperatures for UAH 6, and forecast for 2017 based on data up to August 2017.
UAH 6 - Probability of 2017 Ranking
Rank
Year
Anomaly
Probability
Change
1st
2016
0.51 °C
0.0%
+0.0%
2nd
1998
0.48 °C
0.0%
+0.0%
3rd
2010
0.33 °C
30.4%
+11.0%
4th
2015
0.26 °C
63.8%
-1.4%
5th
2002
0.22 °C
5.6%
-8.7%
6th
2005
0.20 °C
0.2%
-0.6%
7th
2003
0.19 °C
0.0%
-0.2%
8th
2014
0.18 °C
0.0%
+0.0%
This slight rise in the forecast has edged UAH 6 close to the third place set in 2010.
As a result, whilst it's still most likely that 2017 will be 4th warmest, the chances of finishing 3rd have increased somewhat.
Analysis of UAH 6
I'm going to look in some detail at the trend of UAH 6 and what it means for Christopher Monckton's Great Pause.
I'm using UAH 6 for this, as it is the closest current data set to Monckton's preferred RSS 3.3 set.
This is still being published but has now been superseded by version 4, which shows rather more warming.
To be clear, the only reason I am using UAH 6 is that it shows by far the least warming of any data set.
First of all lets look at UAH 6 over its lifetime.
UAH 6 TLT Anomalies in °C compared with 1981 - 2010 base period.
Blue - linear trend.
Red - 12 month moving average.
The peak in 2016 is very similar to that of 1998, but as mentioned above the years before and after have been much warmer.
This can be more clearly seen by looking at a 2 year rolling average.
UAH 6 TLT Anomalies in °C compared with 1981 - 2010 base period.
Blue - linear trend.
Red - 24 month moving average.
UAH 6 continues to set new records averaged over the last 24 months, and is currently 0.15°C warmer than the high point in 1998.
For a clearer picture of the climate, here's the same graph using 20 year averages.
UAH 6 TLT Anomalies in °C compared with 1981 - 2010 base period.
Blue - linear trend.
Red - 20 year moving average.
Whatever the truth behind the Pause, it has had very little impact on the long term trend.
The trend over the entire life of UAH 6 is currently 1.25°C / Century (a lot less than in other data sets).
The trend up to 1997 was just 0.93 °C / Century. A year later it had risen to 1.64 °C / Century.
None of these trends are significantly different from each other.
UAH 6 TLT showing different trend periods.
Blue - trend to August 2017.
Green - trend to 1998.
Red - trend to 1999.
Christopher Monckton's Great Pause
A reminder that Christopher Monckton's Great Pause, which he used to annotate every month in Watt's Up With That, was a ludicrous example of cherry-picking, in which he would take one data set (RSS 3.3), work out the trend starting at each month up to the current month, and then choose the earliest starting month yielding a negative trend.
He would then claim that this represented the start of the Great Pause (his capitalization), and tell his readers exactly how many months it had lasted.
It didn't matter that the actual start would move backwards and forwards each month.
Using Monckton's definition there is currently no Pause.
Or at least not one lasting more than 5 years - taking the strictest definition there has been a pause since May 2015, but I would hope even Monckton has more sense than to talk about a 2 year pause.
Limiting ourselves to trends of at least 5 years, the closes to Monckton's pause is to cherry pick the starting month that gives the slowest rate of warming.
This is December 1997, with a trend of 0.58 °C / Century.
UAH 6 monthly anomalies - with trend lines for the periods before and after December 1997.
But we can just as easily cherry-pick starting dates that will give extremely fast rates of warming.
For example, since April 2005, UAH 6 has been warming at over 2 °C / Century.
Since September 2006, it has been warming at over 3 °C / Century,
and since August 2007, the rate of warming has been more than 4 °C / Century.
Of course all of these steep rises rely on the warm El Niño last year, just as the pause relies on starting with a very warm El Ni˜o.
And none of these Great Warmings are statistically significant, any more than Monckton's Great Pause was.
And, as with the Pause the lines don't meet up.
UAH 6 monthly anomalies - with trend lines for the periods before and after August 2007.
When Will the Pause Return?
Curiously, Christopher Monckton asked the same question back in January, but neglected to even attempt an answer.
Whilst it might have been possible for a brief return in a year or so, if there had been a strong La Niña this year, the fact that temperatures have continued to be so high throughout this year makes any return in the next couple of years highly unlikely,
and unless something very dramatic happens I doubt we will ever see a return to a pause stretching back to before 1998.
To simplify things lets use annual averages, rather than monthly.
Now, assume 2017 does finish up within my prediction interval, but at the low end, i.e. around 0.26 °C, what would it take for the Great Pause to return by the end of 2018?
For this to happen, 2018 would have to average -0.22°C.
That would be a pretty phenomenal drop in temperature in a single year.
It would require 2018 to be the coldest year since 1992.
Alternatively, if 2018 was to drop to -0.1 °C, equal to the coldest single year during the Great Pause, and then stay at that level for the next few years, we still wouldn't see the return of the Pause until 2020.
In other words, for there to be a return of Monckton's Pause anytime in the next few years would require a period of cold unlike anything seen during the last 25 years.
Citations
Analysis for this blog post used R.
R Core Team (2015). R: A language and environment for statistical computing.
R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria. URL
https://www.R-project.org/.
Graphics produced with the GGPlot package
H. Wickham. ggplot2: Elegant Graphics for Data Analysis. Springer-Verlag New
York, 2009.
This is the second part of a continuing series, looking at claims about the pause in 2017 (and already far behind schedule).
In this episode I'm revisiting Christopher Monckton of Brenchleys Great Pause articles on Watts Up With That.
These were a series of monthly articles, lasting almost two years, in which he would inform the public exactly, to the month,
when the Great Pause started, how many months it had lasted,
and how if only it would continue, the climate scare will become unsustainable.
The first Monckton pause article appeared on the 4th March 2014 in WUWT -
No global warming for 17 years, 6 months>.
This put the start date for the pause at September 1996.
This was a very short piece, just two paragraphs, and says nothing about why he chose that month for the start of the trend,
although it's obvious he cherry-picked it to get the result he wanted.
In later, much much longer posts, he confirmed he was cherry-picking the start of each pause by calculating the earliest starting month that would still give a non-positive trend.
By his final post on the subject in February 2016, the start date had moved forward 9 months to June 1997.
This is how Monckton starts his 2014 post
Seventeen and a half years.
Not a flicker of global warming.
The RSS satellite record, the first of the five global-temperature datasets to report its February value, shows a zero trend for an impressive 210 months.
Miss Brevis, send a postcard to Mr Gore:
Saying there's not been a flicker of global warming, shows how misleading looking at a trend line in isolation can be.
The graph fails to show the huge amount of global warming needed to reach the start of Monckton's pause.
The pause starts almost 0.25°C above the previous trend.
Curiously, in Monckton's next pause article,
No global warming for 17 years 8 months,
he calculates how much warming there should have been during the pause, saying there should have been 0.22°C warming since September 1996.
Yet if his pause trend is to be believed more than enough warming happened in a single month than his dubious calculations require.
This is what his original pause looks like now.
The trend since September 1996 is now stronger than the trend leading up to it.
But both trends are a lot less than the trend over the entire satellite era -
this is entirely due to the broken trend line resulting from cherry picking a meaningless split in the overall trend.
By contrast, if you split the trends at the start of 1999 you can get a continuous pair of trends.
The later trend is 1.1°C / century, slower than the previous trend of 1.53°C / century,
but the difference is not statistically significant, and there's still no firm evidence that a simple trend throughout the entire run is the best fit.
Cherry-picking the Data
All of Monckton's Pause claims are based on choosing RSS 3.3 satellite data.
In a Pause update shortly before UAH 6.0 was released in beta format -
El Niño or ñot, the Pause lengthens again,
Monckton was insisting that RSS 3.3 was the least unreliable data set, and insisted that
there was little statistical difference between the RSS and other datasets over the 18-year period of the Great Pause.
This is true, but only because the confidence intervals for any trend over the last 18 years are very large, especially for satellite data.
But this fact just highlights why it makes no sense to choose the set with the smallest trend and claim it as reality.
Waiting for the Return
Monckton's main goal has always to find the longest possible pause and attaches an odd significance to it one day reaching 20 years.
At the end of his final article he puts it in the form of a Freedom Clock, saying
Finally, how long will it be before the Freedom Clock reaches 20 years without any global warming?
If it does, the climate scare will become unsustainable.
Presumably as the pause stopped before reaching 19 years the climate scare is still sustainable,
which is why there seems to be a lot of hope among true believers of the pause that it will shortly return.
In Moncktons final article he says:
The current el Niño, as Bob Tisdale's distinguished series of reports here demonstrates,
is at least as big as the Great el Niño of 1998.
The RSS temperature record is now beginning to reflect its magnitude.
If past events of this kind are a guide, there will be several months' further warming before the downturn in the spike begins.
However, if there is a following la Niña, as there often is,
the Pause may return at some time from the end of this year onward.
Perhaps Bob could address the likelihood of a la Niña in the next of his series of posts on the ENSO phenomenon.
I doubt there was ever any likelihood of the pause returning by the end of 2016.
As things currently stand, even if temperatures were to drop to the levels seen during the La Niña years following the '98 spike,
Monckton still won't see his pause return until 2019.
But so far there's no sign of satellite data dropping to 1999/2000 levels.
In the mean time, it's possible to cherry-pick in the opposite direction - deliberately look for long stretches of fast warming trends.
For example, using RSS 3.3, the earliest starting point where the trend was greater than 1.5°C / century is currently January 1982 - so for the past 35 years and 4 months temperatures have been rising at an accelerated rate (faster than the overall rate of warming) despite 18 years of that being the Great Pause.
This is not the most up to date issue, but I found it amusing.
Whilst looking through some of Christopher Monckton's Great Pause posts on WUWT, I noticed this, in one of his last articles on the subject - The Pause hangs on by its fingernails.
Early on in the extremely long ramblings we get this quote:
The not necessarily reliable Tom Karl of NOAA and the relentlessly campaigning Gavin Schmidt of NASA held a joint press conference to celebrate the grants their rent-seeking organizations can milk out of their assertion that 2015 was the warmest year since 1880.
But they carefully omitted the trend-line from their graph, so I have added it back.
It shows the world warming since 1880 at an unexciting two-thirds of a degree per century
Accompanied by this graph showing the Monckton trend-line
Now apart from the question of why you would want to fit a linear trend over data that clearly isn't linear,
and the fact that Monckton seems to have a problem understanding what the word trend means,
and his curious habit of drawing all trend lines with thick lines and meaningless arrowheads,
there's one major problem with his trend line.
It's completely false!
Here's what the trend line should look like.
It's much steeper than Monckton's line.
The odd thing is that Monckton gets the figures correct.
The trend is 0.67°C / century, which means a complete rise of 0.91°C over the 135 years of the data.
The problem seems to have arisen because NOAA are using the antique Fahrenheit scale, as indicated by the description in the top right of their original graph, saying that 2015 was 1.62°F warmer than the 20th century average.
The scale of the graph is in Fahrenheit, but Monckton has added a caption in the top left of his graph saying that the scale is in °C.
He's then drawing his trend line, scaled to Centigrade.
So his trend shows a line with a rise of 0.91°F, not the actual trend of 0.91°C.
Here's the original NOAA graph showing the correctly labelled temperature scale.
Here's Monckton's graph with the correct trend line in blue.
Corrected version of graph by Christopher Monckton of Brenchley, showing correct trend line in blue.
This may well be an honest mistake by Monckton - the use of obsolete temperature scales by American institutions can cause confusion like this,
but it's convenient that it results in a graph that appears to show less warming.
And it doesn't explain why Monckton removes the label from the original NOAA / NASA graph and replaces it with his own incorrect label.