The general uncertainty as to what is really happening makes it easier to cling to lunatic beliefs. Since nothing is ever quite proved or disproved, the most unmistakable fact can be impudently denied. Moreover, although endlessly brooding on power, victory, defeat, revenge, the nationalist is often somewhat uninterested in what happens in the real world. What he wants is to feel that his own unit is getting the better of some other unit, and he can more easily do this by scoring off an adversary than by examining the facts to see whether they support him.
George Orwell - Notes on Nationalism
My Thoughts On Lying
Although the main purpose of this blog was to draw attention to things that are untrue,
I find it oddly difficult to come straight to the point and call these untruths lies.
This is partly because I'm meek and mild and don't want to be sued,
but there are a couple more objections.
One is that it's difficult to determining when someone is actually lying and when they are just wrong.
It can be a fruitless task trying to separate the genuinely deceitful from the credulous or ignorant.
The other is that whilst the act of lying can be a tool of propagandists, accusing others of lying can be an even more effective propaganda trick.
Claiming your opponents of doing what you continuously do is a great way of confusing the issue,
and at its most successful allows your faithful side to disbelieve any evidence used against you, with the added benefit of allowing your followers to feel superior.
Your enemies are such gullible fools believing their own sides propaganda.
You should be prepared to call out obvious lies, but it's more important to explain why the lie is false rather than just shout LIAR, LIAR.
Look for evidence, ask for sources, don't assume that everything that agrees with your world view is true.
Two years ago there was a strong El Niño, which combined with ongoing global warming,
resulted in 2016 being the warmest year on record, in all data sets.
February 2016 in particular had the warmest anomaly for any month with GISTEMP showing an anomaly of 1.34°C, two tenths warmer than the previous month which was also a record.
In fact using GISTEMP thee 7 months from October 2015 to April 2016 were all more than a degree Celsius above the 1951-1980 base period,
the 7 warmest months on record up to that point.
Since then monthly temperatures have been up and down, with more months over the 1°C mark in 2017, and never lower than 0.69°C.
The one point this really enforces is that global warming never went away, despite the many cherry picked pauses.
But inevitably a record breaking El Niño can be the start of a new pause, or even a cooling trend, when as is inevitable temperatures fall below the trend.
But that's too far away for some people who need to distract from how warm the globe has become.
Welcome to the two year hiatus, or rather the greatest cooling event on record.
This all started with an article on a website called RealClearMarkets, by someone called Aaron Brown.
He appears to be a financial author, and a self confessed libertarian.
He asks the question
Did You Know the Greatest Two-Year Global Cooling Event Just Took Place?
Now he insists in this article that nothing he says should argue against global warming, that he's simply asking why there is no media attention about this event.
I'll give him the benefit of the doubt, but in any event his arguments are incredibly silly.
He starts,
Would it surprise you to learn the greatest global two-year cooling event of the last century just occurred?
From February 2016 to February 2018 (the latest month available) global average temperatures dropped 0.56°C.
You have to go back to 1982-84 for the next biggest two-year drop, 0.47°C—also during the global warming era.
He's already had to add a qualification, it's not the greates event ever, just in the last 100 years.
Then he starts describing the big chill in terms of two little chills and claims that if this big drop were to continue we would be back to 1980s levels in a few months.
I'm not sure if this is correct, but it probably isn't going to happen, so why mention it now?
The 2016-18 Big Chill was composed of two Little Chills, the biggest five month drop ever (February to June 2016) and the fourth biggest (February to June 2017).
A similar event from February to June 2018 would bring global average temperatures below the 1980s average.
February 2018 was colder than February 1998.
Context
The dog that didn't bark in this article or any of thw many posts copying it is any attempt to put this in context.
In particular there is not a single graph showing what this cooling event looks like.
Nor does he mention that the anomaly in February 2018 was still 0.78°C warmer than the 1951-1980 average, that this was the 7th warmest February on record,
or that it is still warmer than 4 years ago.
He makes the point that it is colder than February 1998, but doesn't say by only about 0.1°C, or point out that this means that even after the greatest two year cooling event temperatures are only slightly lower than the record breaking temperature of 20 years ago.
It would be easy to read this talk of a cooling event as implying temperatures are now cold, when they are still some of the warmest on record.
Here's the graph of GISTEMP data with the start and end points of the greatest teo year cooling event marked in red.
Of course the really obvious point is that this is only the greatest cooling because it started on such a warm month.
To put this in even more context, using Brown's technique you should also point out that the two years leading up to this great cooling saw the greatest two year warming event,
not just in the past 100 years, but since records began.
That this warming event was over 0.8°C, far bigger than his cooling event.
More than 0.25°C bigger than the comparative two year warming event of the great El Niño event of 1998.
Then there's this puzzling description of two little chills.
Here's a graph of the last few years, with the start and end months marked.
There's a quick drop from the peak month in February (the first little chill),
but this actually gives us all of the cooling, temperatures in November 2016 were lower as an anomaly than they currently are.
His second little chill ignores the fact there was a rise in temperatures leading up to the second drop.
But that just echos what happened in the years leading up to the big chill - it was preceded by a much bigger warming.
At this point it should be realized that all Brown's descriptions of chills are based on simply comparing the start month to the final month,
and ignoring everything that happens in between.
This is a very bad way of assessing what temperatures are actually doing.
Monthly data is very variable and any difference over two years are likely to be down to chance rather than an actual trend.
In this case the problem is in Brown claiming that the last two years have set a record.
This is true if you ignore a bigger drop 101 years ago, but it depends entirely on this arbitrary two year period.
This graph shows both the 1998 and 2016 strong El Niños, with the peak February temperature and the subsequent February tewo years later.
The obvious point here is that February 2000 was somewhat warmer than January 2000.
If brown based wanted he could have taken the cooling from February 1998 to January 2000 and found it was greater than that from February 2016 to February 2018.
It's arbitrary, and self serving, to call the last two years as the greatest cooling event this century.
A better way of determining cooling trends would be to look at the actual trend over a two year period, using linear regression.
This is a standard technique, though it still doesn't make much sense to look at a two year period it does at least take into account all the data over that period.
The problem is, if you do that Brown's argument that there was anything unusual about the last two years goes out the window.
The fastest recent cooling two year trend was around 17°C / century.
This sounds dramatic, but between 1998 and 2000 it was over 23°C/ century.
More importantly there have been 7 periods over the last century with two year trends faster than the post 2016 big chill,
and many more almost as steep.
This graph shows every 2 year trend over the history of GISTEMP.
Strong two year chill rates happen all the time, just as do strong warming events.
It's about Bias in the Media
Brown's main point is that this is not about the reality of global warming, but about bias in the media.
My point is that statistical cooling outliers garner no media attention.
The global average temperature numbers come out monthly.
If they show a new hottest year on record, that's a big story.
If they show a big increase over the previous month, or the same month in the previous year, that's a story.
If they represent a sequence of warming months or years, that's a story.
When they show cooling of any sort—and there have been more cooling months than warming months since anthropogenic warming began—there's no story.
Now I wouldn't disagree that the media has biases, and that in reporting on climate change they are often wrong or simplistic.
I'd also agree that it is a problem that reporting on climate change is often limited to mentioning when record breaking years,
and focusing on statistical outliers, rather than the more important concerns of ongoing warming.
But, constant complaints of bias often show more about the accusers own bias.
They want the things that support there beliefs to be reported.
Brown tries to argue that the recent two year cooling event should be as newsworthy as 2016 being the warmest year on record based entirely on the statistical likelihoods of the two events.
He says that the cooling event was a three sigma event, something that only happens rarely, whereas warmest years happen every 8 years or so.
But apart from the fact that the two year cooling event isn't really a 3 sigma event, one you understand the large amount of cherry picking associated with it.,
the problem is on wanting to decide what stories are covered based only on how likely the event is.
He thinks events that are rare are more newsworthy than events that are important.
Record breaking hot years might happen 12% of the time, but that's still an important news story given both what it tells us about global warming and the effects on the planet.
By contrast his great cooling means nothing except the planet is back on it's regular warming track.
Aftermath
Aaron Brown's piece has had an odd history since it appeared on the 24th April.
Almost immediately James Delingpole was ripping it off for Breitbart, in a piece called Earth in ‘Greatest Two-Year Cooling Event in a Century’ Shock, 26 April.
This essentially repeats what Brown says, but more forcefully, and adds even more confusion.
Delingpole tries to put the shocking event in context:
To put this temperature drop in context, consider that this is enough to offset by more than half the entirety of the global warming the planet has experienced since the end of the 19th century.
This is a common trick, point to a drop lasting a few months, claim it wipes out a certain percentage of the last century of warming,
fail to distinguish between long term warming averaged over decades and a single month, and ignore the fact that the actual drop was from a much higher starting point, so that even after this drop nothing has been offset.
In fact February 2018 was over a degree warmer than the late 19th century average - far from offsetting any warming it has added 25% to Delingpole's claimed warming.
He finishes by asserting that
As we know from long experience, if it had been the other way round –
if the planet had warmed by 0.56 degrees C rather than cooled,
the media would have been all over it.
Except we don't have to imagine that, the world did warm by far more than that, between February 2014 and February 2016 the world warmed by over 0.8°C,
over 50% more than the shocking cooling, and adding as much warming as all the warming of the past century.
Yet no-one seems to have mentioned that fact, as they were too busy talking about how February had been the warmest month on record.
Three weeks after the Brown piece, something called Investor's Business Daily had an editorial called
Don’t Tell Anyone, But We Just Had Two Years Of Record-Breaking Global Cooling
again referencing the Brown piece and complaining that no other news outlet had picked up on it in three weeks.
GWPF reproduced the editorial, WUWT copied the GWPF copy of the original without acknowledging either.
The WUWT article prompted me to add some graphs putting the record breaking global cooling in context in their comments.
Had an usually large set of angry responses, suggesting I might have hit a nerve.
The main complain was that I was using GISTEMP, which I was repeatedly told was garbage, and not caring that that was the data set Brown uses.
In fact different data sets won't show the record.
Then we had Tony Heller, suddenly pointing out that there had been the greatest two year drop in temperature in a century - two months after it had happened and without acknowledging Brown's original, or any of the other articles that had already mentioned it.
In his post Earth Cooling Fastest In A Century – Since Trump Took Office, he makes a lame joke about how all the cooling happened under Trump.
Last year, scientists said Earth was record hot and it was Donald Trump’s fault.
But they had it backwards.
The prior warming was Obama’s fault, as Trump wasn’t in office yet.
The cooling since 2016 is under Trump’s watch.
Not that it matters but this isn't really true.
Most of the cooling happened before Trump was elected.
Temperatures went up after his election.
Yet it's strange that whilst every one is complaining about the press not noticing or caring about the greatest two year cooling event, even the sceptical websites failed to report on this momentous event until someone else pointed it out to them.
Christopher Monckton of Brenchley is back at Watt's Up With That with the first of what promises to be a series of articles about IPCC projections.
The article is
Tamper, tamper! How They failed to hide the gulf between predicted and observed warming
.
In it he revisits his usual argument that the rate of warming in the slowest warming data set (UAH 6) does not match the rate of warming predicted in the oldest IPCC report from 1990.
He also says that all the data sets have been tampered with -
in the article he objects to the changes to RSS 4, but in the comments he also says that the tampering charge applies to all data sets including UAH 6.
The only reason for using that particular data set was that it was the first to be released, and not because it happens to be the coolest.
He uses the oldest IPCC projections, by definition the least reliable, from 1990 and the slowest warming data set (UAH 6) to claim that there has only been half as much warming as predicted.
As Fig. 1 shows, in the 39 years 1 month from December 1978 to December 2017, the planet has warmed by half a Celsius degree.
But that is equivalent to 1.28 C°/century, or little more than one-third of the 3.3 C°/century predicted with
substantial confidence by IPCC in 1990 and also by the fifth-generation general-circulation models of the
Climate Model Intercomparison Project in 2013.
This is wrong on most counts.
He quotes the 1990 IPCC report as saying with substantial confidence a rate of warming of 3.3°C / century.
This figure does not appear in the report, and the figure they do state (0.3°C / decade) is not described as having substantial confidence.
What the report says is they have ... substantial confidence that models can predict at least the broad scale features of climate change.
(My emphasis.)
He also claims the latest IPCC projections are the same as those from the 1990s, but this is also wrong.
His 3.3°C / century warming is somewhere between two of the IPCC scenarios, but only for long term warming, up to the end of the century.
In the short term it says all scenarios are similar and projects between 0.3 and 0.7°C warming between 1995 and 2025 (using 20 year averages).
Using Monckton's trick of converting all warming projections to linear trends this is a rate of warming of between 1°C / century and 2.3°C / century.
Even UAH 6 is within these bounds.
But, what interests me most is where Monckton gets his 3.3°C / century figure from, and why this is faster than what he was claiming they said only a couple of years ago.
Back in May 2016 Monckton introduced the Global Warming Speedometer.
(Never to be seen again).
In this he claimed the 1990 IPCC report predicted a rate of warming of 2.8°C / century, with a lower bound of 1.9°C / century.
What the 1990 IPCC Report Said
The main description of future warming is made in page xxii of the first IPCC report.
They say that temperatures are likely to raise at a rate of 0.3°C / decade.
They then give figures for the amount of warming both from the pre-industrial period and the present (ie 1990).
They define the pre-industrial period as 1750-1800 (page 22) or just 1765 (page 177).
They state that by the the end of the century temperatures will be 4°C warmer than the pre-industrial period, and 3°C warmer from present.
They also say this will mean that by 2025 global temperatures will be 2°C warmer than pre-industrial levels, and 1°C from present temperatures.
This is illustrated with this graph, showing the likely warming and the upper and lower bounds.
However they define the pre-industrail period, it's clear from their figures and the graph that they consider there has been 1°C of warming from pre-industrail to 1990.
What's not clear is how precise these figures are meant to be, all temperature increases are given to whole degrees.
The projected 1°C by 2025 would translate to an average warming rate of 2.8°C / century, and this appear to be how Monckton calculated the rate for his speedometer,
although he credits this to page xxiv.
This is interesting as that page suggests a slower rate of warming.
Page xxiv quotes a projection of 1.8°C above pre-industrial levels by 2030.
Obviously this is less than the 2°C by 2025 they give on page xxii.
Taking this with the supposed 1°C warming up to present would suggest a projected 0.8°C warming over the 40 years from 1990 to 2030;
a rate of 2°C / century, with low and high estimates of 1.4°C and 3.0°C / century.
This would mean most data sets are well within the projected warming rates, and UAH 6 is only slightly below the lower estimate.
So why does Monckton believe that page xxiv is actually claiming a warming rate of 3.3 °C / century?
In response to a question from DWR54 he says,
In reply to the furtively anonymous “DWR54” p. xxiv of IPCC (1990) says:
“The numbers given below are based on high-resolution models,
scaled to be consistent with our best estimate of global mean warming of 1.8 C by 2030
[compared with pre-industrial temperatures] …
the numbers below should be reduced by 30% for the low estimate or increased by 50% for the high estimate.”
There had been 0.45 K global warming in the industrial era, so IPCC was predicting 1.35 K of warming over 4.1 decades, equivalent to 3.3 K/century.
In the passages cited by “DWR54”, IPCC rounded this value to 3 K.
His entire argument is based on the claim that there had only been 0.45°C warming from the pre-industrial period by 1990,
and that the IPCC were predicting an additional 1.35°C warming by 2030.
This does not agree with anything they say elsewhere and does not agree with their graph.
Here (in red) is what Monckton's 1.35°C of warming looks like.
Monckton's 0.45°C figure probably comes from page 199 of the IPCC report.
This is a chapter on instrument measurements, in which they say that the world is probably 0.45 ± 0.15°C warmer than the late 19th century.
There are many problems with Monckton using this figure.
For a start it isn't for warming from the pre-industrial period, but from the late 19th century.
Then there's the way he ignores the large uncertainty in the stated figure.
But the big problem is that whatever the merits of the 0.45°C figure, it isn't the one the IPCC used when they stated the warming rates from the pre-industrial period on pages xxii and xxiv.
You cannot simply take an unrelated figure from a different part of the report,
use it to add an extra 0.55°C to the expected warming and claim that's what the IPCC really meant - with substantial confidence.
In short - Monckton has literally made up a figure, and then quoted it as if it was a direct figure from the IPCC.
Monckton's Own Predictions
In commenting on Monckton's article I couldn't resist pointing out one of his own predictions, made in front of a congressional hearing in 2009.
He claimed then that global temperatures might only rise by 0.5°F by the end of the century,
that is about 0.28°C.
This means that by Monckton's own logic, temperatures are warming more than 4 times faster than his prediction, even using the slowest rising UAH data.
When I mentioned this in the comments, Monckton said he couldn't remember making such a prediction
In reply to Bellman, I do not recollect having predicted in 2009 that global warming would be only 0.25 K/century.
I said that at that time the warming rate was equivalent to 0.25 K/century.
I have published a series of papers in which the best estimate of warming is around 1.2-1.3 K/century.
That warming rate, and no higher rate, is consistent with the officially estimated net anthropogenic forcings in the industrial era.
His exact words, both in written and spoken testimony to congress, were
This century we may warm the world by half a Fahrenheit degree, if that.
It's not clear why he thinks the warming rate at the time was 0.25°C / century.
At the time he was saying there had been rapid cooling (but that's another story).
Possibly he did make a mistake both in his written and spoken testimony - elsewhere in the speech he suggests warming may be as much as 2°F by the end of the century.
But it does follow another habit of stating predictions with no indication of doubt.
For example in 2015 he said:
No warming has yet arisen this century.
Warming may be 0.6 K by 2100, could be as low as 0.4° K and will not exceed 1° K.
Now he's saying the most likely warming rate is 1.2 - 1.3 °C / century.
Yet he wants to hold the IPCC to account for projections made almost 30 years ago.
The paper's behind a paywall, but from the abstract and the Climate Change article it seems they modeled the
likelihood that any given record breaking global temperature year would have been a record without human influence.
They conclude that whilst it's almost certain that most of the records set after 1980 would not have been set without increasing CO2,
there is also a good probability, greater than 50%, that the records from 1937 through the 40s, would not have been set without human influence.
As the abstract says:
We find a significant human contribution to the probability of record-breaking global temperature events as early as the 1930s.
Since then, all the last 16 record-breaking hot years globally had an anthropogenic contribution to their probability of occurrence.
I not sure about the emphasis on record breaking years,
and it is surprising that the relatively small CO2 rise in the late 30s had a detectable effect on temperatures.
I think it's clear that CO2 was not the main reason for the high temperatures.
But the paper is not claiming it was - just that it would have been less likely to get a record high temperature without the additional boost of CO2.
Tony Heller, naturally, thinks the whole report is not just wrong but insists the authors hadn't looked at any data,
and were unaware of what the CO2 levels were in the 30s.
Both claims that are obviously wrong.
He then makes the claim there is no correlation between CO2 and temperature.
Had these scientists actually looked at any data,
they would have known that the heat of the 1930's peaked at 310 PPM CO2, and the heat has declined as CO2 increased.
There is no correlation between CO2 and heatwaves.
There may be an attempt to move the goalposts here, by quietly shifting to talking about heatwaves,
when the paper is only talking about temperatures.
He's also failed to notice that temperatures did not peak in the 30s, but in the 40s.
He illustrates his claim about the lack of a correlation between CO2 and temperatures with this graph.
To get this he's had to exclude most of the data.
First he's limited the graph to just the US, when the report is clearly talking about global temperatures.
This has the usual problem that temperatures were much warmer in the US during the 30s than they were in the globe as a whole.
Secondly, Heller limits the graph to just summer months.
The US heat of the 30s were mostly associated with summer, later warming more with winter.
NOAA's figures show annual US temperatures increasing at almost twice the rate as US summer temperatures.
Thirdly, he only looks at maximum temperatures, rather than average daily temperatures.
NOAA's figures show minimum summer US temperatures increasing at twice the rate as maximum temperatures.
Finally, he uses his own naive calculations rather than relying on official data such as from NOAA.
His calculations seem to just take an average of all stations, which has many potential problems.
NOAA's own figures still show a slight rise over the entire period in US Summer Maximum temperatures,
whilst Heller's figures show a slight decrease.
This is what the graph looks like if you use NOAA's figures rather than Heller's.
Comparison of US Summer (June - August) Maximum temperatures with CO2 (ppm)
In both cases the correlation is not statistically significant, but the one using NOAA data is positive -
the one using Heller data is negative.
If we look at the data that actually matters as far as the research goes, global annual mean temperatures,
the correlation with CO2 is obvious and statistically significant.
Comparison of Annual Temperature Anomalies (in °C) with Atmospheric CO2 (ppm)
Of course, this doesn't prove CO2 is the cause of global warming - just that the correlation exists.
Tony Heller does this all the time.
He makes his own crude calculations based on a limited selection of the available data, and then claims that any research that doesn't agree with his
figures is not just wrong, but a lie.
This is another post, possibly the last, in my series looking at the pause that this been claimed happened in the early part of the 21st century.
Last time I looked at a post from Watt's Up With That, by Dr David Whitehouse,
NEW STUDY CONFIRMS: THE WARMING 'PAUSE' IS REAL AND REVEALING
.
(Archived version here, as the original is currently missing graphics.)
I looked at the specific claim of global warming stopping in 1998, made by Bob Carter,
and pointed out that apart from being a very short period,
it required a huge increase in the overall rate of warming.
In this post I'll look at yet another claim of a pause made by Dr Whitehouse in the article.
This pause starts in in 2001 and lasting 13 years.
Meet the New Pause
Dr Whitehouse's pause is introduced when he talks about the Nature report
saying there are multiple definitions of the pause:
What the authors miss, with their three definitions of the pause, is a simple fact we have often pointed out.
Look at HadCRUT4 from 2001 (after the 1999-2000 El Nino/La Nina event) until 2014 (before the start of the recent El Nino event)
and you will see the temperature is flat.
Apart from the recent El Nino there has been no global increase since 2001,
even though there have been El Ninos and La Ninas in that period.
Now that's what I call a pause.
So why does Whitehouse start his pause in 2001, when Carter was convinced warming had stopped in 1998?
The answer is that Whitehouse wants to insist that all the warming over the last couple of years was the result of a strong El Niño,
and should not be included in any warming trend as it is not caused by humans.
As he says,
The pause ended not because of gradual global warming but because of a natural weather event whose temporary
increased rate of global warming was far too large to be anthropogenic.
There's some truth in that; it would be completely wrong to look at the past 7 years and claim it shows accelerated warming when you are ending on a couple of unusually hot years.
If you did, you could claim that the world has been warming at a rate of over 5 °C / century since 2011, 3 times the rate since 1970.
Of course, no-one would claim a 7 year trend as having any meaning.
Trend for HadCRUT 4, since 2010.
Whitehouse doesn't want to allow a Strong El Niño to be counted as part of a trend, but it would then be a touch hypocritical to point to Carter's Pause - which started on a strong El Niño - as evidence of no warming.
By shifting the start of the pause to 2001, Whitehouse is trying to show that the pause doesn't depend on the 1998 El Niño.
His pause doesn't start with an El Niño, and is just an arbitrary period of 13 years that contains both El Niños and La Niñas.
The problem is he's still being very selective in his starting point.
Why not look at the trend from 1999 if all you wanted to do was discount the 1998 El Niño?
Because then he would have a modest amount of warming (0.87° / century).
Or why not calculate the trend including both El Niños?
Then the trend would be 1.33 °C / century.
The period 2001 to 2013 is selected precisely
because it gives a 13 year period of near zero warming.
It is a cherry-pick.
Before and After the Pause
What Whitehouse's pause does illustrate is that whilst 1998 has a big impact on the rate of warming, it isn't the only factor.
To illustrate the problem let's play my usual game of asking what impact these 13 years of no-warming had on the overall rate of warming.
I'll follow Bob Carter's definition of the warming period and look at the trend starting in 1970.
The trend before the 1998 El Niño, from 1970-1997 was 1.56°C / century.
By the start of the Whitehouse Pause the 1970-2000 trend had risen to 1.66.
Whitehouse could argue that this rise was only due to the natural 1998 El Niño and the trend up to 1997 was the true rate of global warming,
but the difference is minor and I'll assume that the figure of 1.66 is the underlying rate of warming before the pause.
So what would you expect to happen to the trend by the end of the 13 year Whitehouse Pause?
Amazingly, the trend up to the end of the Whitehouse Pause is identical to the trend to the start of the pause.
This is purely a coincidence - choosing different start years would have produced different results.
But it does illustrate the point that all these pauses have had no significant effect on the overall trend.
This is not what you would expect if global warming had really stopped, or slowed down.
Annotating the Pause
To explain how it's possible that Whitehouse can show 13 years of zero warming, yet it not have any effect on the underlying trend I'll take a painfully long
look at the HadCRUT temperatures, year-by-year.
The following graph shows annual anomalies since 1970 to 2000, just before the start of the Whitehouse Pause.
The trend line is the trend from 1970-2000, projected up to the current day.
If, at the end of 2000, you felt that this trend was a reasonable model of how warming would continue - that is you were not expecting a pause,
you would expect future years to be close to the trend line, rising slowly, but with roughly as many years below the line as above it.
In all the following graphs this trend line is unchanged, that is it represents the trend as it would have been predicted from 2000.
Years belonging to the Whitehouse Pause are marked in red.
Let's just look at the first year of the pause, 2001.
2001 was hot, remarkably so considering it was not an El Niño year.
It was the second warmest year on record, marginally warmer than 1997 and much warmer than any year before 1997.
It's also warmer than the trend, which starts to explain why it is the first year of the Whitehouse Pause.
Now jump forward to 2007, half way through the Whitehouse Pause.
This is where it gets interesting.
2001 was warm, but 2002 was warmer, 2003 even warmer, and 2005 warmer still.
If it hadn't been for 1998, HadCRUT would be showing 4 record breaking years in a 5 year period.
In fact 2005 is a new record, narrowly beating 1998.
More importantly, each of the first 7 years, is above the trend line.
That's an unusually long run of warm years, and it's no coincidence that this is the first half of the Whitehouse Pause.
Now at this point, if you were an observer at the end of 2007, you might be wondering if something had happened to the climate -
had the rate of warming accelerated, had we moved into a new phase of warming where temperatures were going to be warmer even than the post '98 El Niño suggested?
Or was it just a chance that there had been 7 hot years in a row?
If it was chance and the trend was a good estimate of future warming there would be a good possibility of cooler years appearing later.
And that's exactly what we see over the next 6 years.
During the next 6 years, 4 were below the trend, only 2 above it.
The two coldest years, both La Niña years, were well below the trend, though there was also one record breaking El Niño year in 2010.
I find it difficult see any evidence that HadCRUT temperatures between 2001 and 2013 were not in keeping with the trend up to 2001.
Compared with the projected trend, there were more warmer than cooler years, but not significantly more.
The only reason Whitehouse can claim any sort of pause is that more of the warmer years happened at the start of the period, and more of the colder years happened in the later half.
The last two years have been very warm, and yes this is in part because of the recent El Niño.
But, they are not so far above the trend line as 1998.
If you accept warming has continued unabated since 2000, there is nothing too surprising here -
the absolute warmth of the last two years are a result of the strong El Niño, on top of the underlying trend.
But, if you believe that global warming stopped in 2000, then the El Niño was exceptionally warm,
which raises the question of why it was so extreme.
The above is what the 20th century looked like compared with an unchanged rate of warming.
The following shows what it looked like compared with a trend that stops in 2000, as Whitehouse is implying.
Annual HadCRUT4 anomalies, 1970 - 2016. Trend from 1970 - 2000, with phony pause trend from 2001 in red.
Every year of his pause was warmer than what would be expected if the pause was real.
Of course, this isn't the pause Dr Whitehouse shows.
He shows the actual trend through the 13 years without the context of the previous years, giving the impression that warming simply stopped in 2000.
Here's what the actual pause trend line looks like.
Annual HadCRUT4 anomalies, 1970 - 2016. Trend from 1970 - 2000 in blue, and trend from 2001 - 2013 in red.
As with other pauses, the flat line requires a big rise in temperatures at its start.
Following on from my last post here's another interesting example of Tony Heller
using odd statistics to make a point.
In this case however it isn't so much the oddness of his statistics that are a problem, it's his entire argument.
The post in question The Trouble With Satellites,
which claims that satellites are exaggerating global warming by starting at an exceptionally cold period.
It's a long post, but the only meat is in the first couple and final paragraphs, and can be summarized thus:
Whilst Satellite data is infinitely better than surface data, it has a major problem in only going back to 1979.
This was the coldest period in the US in the last 90 years,
and so any rise in temperatures since then is misleading.
Therefore Heller sees little or no evidence that Earth is warmer now than it was in 1940.
The first point is debatable - Heller obviously prefers satellites because they show slightly less warming especially this century -
but both satellite and surface data have different problems and where there are differences there's no good reason to assume one must be correct and the other wrong.
But I agree that one advantage surface data has over satellites is their longer reach.
That satellites only going back 40 years makes it difficult to put any differences in perspective.
It's the second point that is the main problem.
Heller says:
But there is a huge problem with satellite temperatures.
They start in 1979, which was the coldest period of the last 90 years in the US.
The frequency of below 0F (-18C) nights peaked in 1979, and then dropped in half by the year 2000, before starting to increase again.
One obvious problem here is that, as always he's only looking at the US, which tells us little about global temperatures.
Even then, Heller is vague about what he means by 1979 being the coldest period in 90 years.
His graph shows a 5 year rolling average of the percentage of days below 0°F, that's around -18°C in real money.
As with his hot summer data this is a dubious way of measuring how cold the US was around 1979;
obviously it's only going to show winter weather, and it will only be a small part of the US that will affect the graph.
As it happens, he didn't really need to go to all the trouble of inventing weird measures.
NOAA's own website shows that 1979 was indeed the coldest winter on record, not just in the last 90 years.
Beating the previous record set in 1936 by over 1°F.
Even if, more logically, we look at the whole year, 1979 was also cold in the USA. Annual US temperature
Not quite the coldest in 90 years (1929 beats it by a smidgen), but pretty much.
But if we look at the 5 year average, as Heller seems to be, we see that the first 5 years of the satellite era (1979-1983),
was not at all the coldest period in the last 90 years.
But if we don't put America first, and instead look at global temperatures, the first 5 years of the satellite era were at a local high,
warmer than the warm 1940s.
Heller's claim that satellites started at the coldest period of the last 90 years, is meaningless.
As far as hi closing remark that he can see no evidence that current temperatures are warmer than the 40s,
this may well be correct as far as Heller's eyes are concerned.
I assume he's not looking very hard, and can easily disregard any evidence to the contrary as fraud.
But as an example that there is some evidence that temperatures are warmer than the 40s, we can use Heller's own technique of aligning 5 year averages at the start of the satellite era.
Satellite temperatures are around 0.4°C above the mid-40s peak.
If we do what Heller seems to prefer and use land only data the warming is even greater compared with the 40s; around 0.7°C warmer.
One final point though, using the first 5 years of the satellite data as a base point is not logical.
It makes an assumption that satellite and surface data precisely agreed with each other at the start and have been drifting apart ever since.
But there's no reason to suppose the years 1979-83 were the the same - it's just as plausible that the satellites were too high (or the surface too low) at the start and are becoming more accurate later.
In fact this seems quite likely when you consider that the first 5 years include a strong El Niño, and satellites usually show more warming than surface data during El Niños.
Changing the offset slightly can produce a slightly more consistent comparison.
Tony Heller (aka Steve Goddard) has one main claim on his Deplorable Climate Science site,
that climate scientists at NASA and NOAA are criminals who are perpetuating the biggest fraud in science history, by adjusting their data sets.
Surface data was nearly infallible 40 years ago, and any changes since then have moved us further from reality.
It is not possible, in his view, that changes might represent honest efforts to improve the data or to remove past errors.
For this to be true every organization producing surface temperature records must be part of this conspiracy,
as must the RSS satellite data now that version 4 is out showing similar levels of warming.
Even Roy Spencer and John Christy producers of the UAH data were part of this fraud, when they were promoting UAH version 5.6 showing similar levels of warming to surface data.
Indeed, Heller accuses them of fraud here, couple of years ago Cooling the Past at UAH.
An Example
A recent blog post by Heller had a claim of adjustments that caught my eye
No Global Warming For 25 Years.
He starts by claiming there's been no warming for 25 years, before insisting that as NASA's data shows warming over 25 years they must be fraudulent.
Then he makes a specific claim that NASA made an adjustment in the month following Trump's election.
The first claim is obviously wrong, the second turned out to be correct, but Heller gets the effect completely wrong.
No Warming?
The claim that there's been no warming for 25 years is bogus.
Heller's talking about RSS 3.3 and actually uses a 26 and a half year period, starting mid-1990.
Here's a graph showing RSS 3.3 over that period:
RSS 3.3 has been warming at the rate of 1.36 °C / century over Heller's period, and that trend is statistically significant.
His claim that NASA show 0.5 °C more warming than RSS 3.3 is therefore exaggerated.
NASA's rate of warming over the same period, is 1.96 °C / century.
Over the past 26.5 years RSS 3.3 has warmed 0.36 °C and NASA 0.52 °C.
The difference between NASA and RSS is 0.16 °C, not the 0.5 °C Heller claims.
The Adjustments
Comparing NASA's data and RSS, Heller says:
Agreement between the satellite and surface temperature data was good until about the year 2000,
but since then NASA has been continuously tampering with their data to create
the impression of non-existent warming.
Just during the month after the election NASA altered their data even further.
He justifies that final claim with this graph.
Graph from The Deplorable Climate Science Blog
The first thing to note is that he's shifted to land only data - ignoring the 70% of the globe that is ocean.
This is a problem as it will exaggerate the significance of any adjustments made to the land data.
Heller's graph shows a comparison between the December and November NASA data, using a 5 year average, with December being around 0.02 °C warmer.
His graph only goes back to the end of the 20th century, so it's not possible to see if this has an effect on the overall warming starting, say, from the mid 70s.
I checked the changes for myself using old data downloaded from the Wayback Machine.
One slight problem is that it isn't entirely clear which months Heller is comparing.
December could mean the data released in December (which would go up to November), or it could mean the data released in January which includes the results for December.
Therefore I looked at the last 3 releases, labelled October, November and December in my graph.
The labels refer to the month the data goes up to.
For example, December is the most up to date version, released in January with results up to December.
Here's my version of Heller's graph - showing a 60 month rolling average for each set.
5 year rolling mean anomalies for three different versions of GISTEMP land data.
This shows Heller is partly correct, there have been adjustments in both of the last two months.
But it also shows Heller's main claim is wrong.
His graph shows the December data is warmer than November's.
But mine shows the reverse -
November is cooler than October,
December is cooler than November.
But how significant are these changes?
Here's the graph extended back to the mid-20th century.
5 year rolling mean anomalies for three different versions of GISTEMP land data.
The adjustments are reversed in the mid-70s; December is slightly warmer, which means the rate of warming since then will have been reduced.
But the graph also shows that these adjustments are not that large.
The effect on the warming rate since 1975 (up to October 2017) are:
Data Set
Rate in °C / century
October 2016
2.23
November 2016
2.18
December 2016
2.16
Over the last two months, NASA's tampering has reduced the rate of warming by 0.07 °C per century.
This is pretty trivial to start with, but remember this is land only data, and only about 30% of the globe.
Here's what the adjustments look like when you look at land and ocean.
5 year rolling mean anomalies for three different versions of GISTEMP global data.
The adjustments are much smaller,
and when you look at a longer time scale -
5 year rolling mean anomalies for three different versions of GISTEMP global data.
they virtually disappear.
For global data the rate of change since 1975 is nearly identical for each set, changing from 1.83 °C / century in October, to 1.82 °C / century in December.
Conclusion
None of this is to suggest Tony Heller is being fraudulent in claiming NASA increased warming over the last few months,
when they actually reduced it.
It's entirely possible this was an honest mistake on Heller's part, though it does suggest some degree of confirmation bias -
he sees a difference and assumes the direction that confirms his prejudices.
The main point, is that it's easy to focus on minor changes that have little impact on the bigger picture,
and to assume that changes to the data are fraudulent, rather than an honest attempt to iprove the quality of the data.
There's a lot more in Heller's post, but it all tends to be on the same theme - the assumption that adjustments are fraud.
One final point though - whilst Heller gives the impression that all these changes are criminal,
you can find all the major changes plotted on NASA's own site, here.
So, the question is, what sort of devious secret cable of evil scientists put all the evidence exposing their criminal activity on their own website?
I'll have the next update for 2016 soon, but with Roy Spencer announcing
that UAH rose slightly in November, it seems highly likely that all datasets will make
2016 the warmest year on record.
The joke has always been that in a few years time this will lead to 2016 being declared the start of a new pause.
Except we didn't have to wait that long.
In the last few days there's been a flurry of nonsensical articles
pointing to the rapid decline of temperatures following on the peak of the recent El Niño,
as evidence for the end of global warming, or the start of a new ice age, or whatever.
Tamino has some great articles detailing the sorry history:
Global average temperatures over land have plummeted by more than 1C since the middle of this year – their biggest and steepest fall on record.
The news comes amid mounting evidence that the recent run of world record high temperatures is about to end.
The fall, revealed by Nasa satellite measurements of the lower atmosphere, has been caused by the end of El Nino –
the warming of surface waters in a vast area of the Pacific west of Central America.
The second two points are obvious and irrelevant.
Of course the run of record breaking weather will end, it would be terrifying if it didn't.
And you don't need NASA to tell you that the end of an El Niño causes a fall in temperatures.
Tellingly, Rose never quotes a source for the data he's using, but it's clearly the RSS v3.3 TLT land data.
But using that source his claim that temperatures have plummeted by more than 1C since the middle of this year is not correct -
they've dropped about 0.5 ° C since the middle of the year - you have to go back to March to make the case for a drop of 1 °C.
Rose claims that this is the biggest and steepest fall on record, but doesn't back this up with any figures.
Nor does he really explain what significance he attaches to this fall.
If the fall is simply the fall from a very high peak, it means nothing and is expected.
If he's suggesting that this trend is meaningful and will continue he's almost certainly going to be wrong.
(In fact as I write November's RSS figures have been published and show land temperatures rose by over 0.2 ° C.)
But he's wrong to claim that this is the sharpest fall on record (assuming he means over any 8 month period).
The trend from March to October was -127.6 ° C / century,
which alone should tell you how meaningless an 8 month trend is.
But this is only the 6th sharpest 8 month fall.
By contrast the 8 months from August 2015 to March this year saw an upward trend of 156.3 ° C / century.
This was the steepest 8 month rise in RSS TLT land temperature history.
I suspect that what Rose actually did was take the difference between the temperatures for March and October.
That does give you the claimed biggest difference, but it's a terrible way to calculate the steepness of the fall.
It ignores all the months between the start and finish, and in this case gives far to much prominence to that single cool final month.
But the main question is why did he only refer to land temperatures, rather than global temperatures?
It's difficult to avoid the suspicion that it's purely cherry-picking.
Here's a graph showing the last 2 years of RSS 3.3 TLT data for both land and global temperatures.
It's obvious from the graph that the peak of El Niño was much higher over land,
and there was one very big drop in October over land, compared with a much smaller one globally.
Rose's justification for only looking at land values is:
The satellite measurements over land respond quickly to El Nino and La Nina.
Temperatures over the sea are also falling, but not as fast, because the sea retains heat for longer.
This gives the impression that sea values will catch up with the land values, but this is not really true.
It isn't that the land responds more quickly than the sea, it's that the land responds more strongly.
To illustrate the problem, here's a comparison of the entire data set for RSS using a 12 month rolling average.
A few things seem obvious from this graph:
There's no evidence that the globe responds slower to El Niño or La Niña events. The peaks and troughs are happening at the same time.
Land values always show higher peaks during El Niños, and bigger drops during La Niñas
The difference between the two values in 2016 was the biggest on record.
The global peak in 2016 was higher than the super El Niño peak in 1998, but the land only peak in 2016 was much higher than the one in 1998.
In part this can be explained by the fact that land only temperatures are increasing faster than global temperatures.
To put figures on that last point -
the global trend given by RSS 3.3 over the entire satellite era is 1.36 ° C / century.
But for land only the trend is 1.79 ° C / century.
Which raises one obvious question - do those trying to deny the existence of global warming really want to emphasize the land only data?
Post Script
It should also be mentioned that all the above is using the old 3.3 version of RSS.
The newer version 4 (TTT, land) only shows a 0.54 ° C drop between March and October, whilst November 2016 sets the record for warmest November.
It has now been conclusively proved that global warming is not a problem.
The science is settled.
That at least is the impression Piers Corbyn came away with from a recent 2 day conference in London.
The amazing international parade of excellent Presentations from highly qualified and informed scientists and researchers in meteorology,
astrophysics and other professions in Meteorological production and academia
proved beyond a shadow of doubt that the man-made climate change story is a pack of lies and
delusional nonsense both in general terms and in every specific field of claims involving temperatures,
sea levels, ice and weather extremes.
He goes on to say (in red)
... no honest scientist can now come forth with any evidence that the Climate Change story is
anything other than a heap of POLITICALLY DRIVEN delusional nonsense and fraud.
Fortunately I am not not a scientist, honest or otherwise, so can talk about the evidence.
New Dawn
The conference was called The New Dawn Of Truth which sounds like it's either a new age magazine or the latest neo-fascist party.
with a logo that could apply to either.
(As far as I can see, there's no relation with the New Dawn magazine.)
The two day conference was put on by an organization calling itself the Independent Committee on Geoethics,
whose members include Christopher Monckton.
It's surprising this revolutionary conference hasn't received more attention on skeptical sites -
Watt's Up With That carried one story about it (written by Christopher Monckton, a founding member of the committee),
but with a disclaimer from Watts:
While I carry this story on WUWT for informational purposes,
that should in no way imply that I endorse the topics of the conference itself or the speakers.
But since then there's only been an oblique reference in this post,
where he says that on seeing a couple of the papers I knew then I would not attend this conference, even if invited.
This post did not go down to well with one of the other presenters at the conference, Roger Tallbloke.
Piers Corbyn's Contribution
Corbyn's presentation - The total failure of the ManMade Climate Change story.
has a slide show here.
There's also a video of his 20 minute lecture which doesn't add much to the slides.
Considering the promises of the title it's all rather disappointing - nothing new at all.
Just the same arguments he's been putting forward for years and mostly the same slides,
not even updated to reflect the fact it is now 2016.
However, it does give me an excuse to comment on a few of Piers Corbyn's claims.
Self Promotion
Around a quarter of the slides (and half the lecture) are about how good Corbyn's WeatherAction is at forecasting the weather.
He's implying that this proves CO2 is not responsible for climate change.
That's because his forecasting relies on the claim that solar activity controls the weather - and therefore is the only factor that controls the climate.
But his logic is wrong.
Even if his forecasts were accurate it would not prove that solar activity was the cause of the weather.
Corbyn keeps his methods a closely guarded secret, but they include factors other than solar activity.
Unless he publishes his research there is no way of knowing how much his success is due to solar factors.
Even if solar activity could be used to predict weather, it would not prove that the sun controls the climate.
Climate and weather are very different things.
Even if the sun does have an effect on the climate (it probably does), this does not mean that CO2 has no affect on the climate.
Moreover, I've yet to see any convincing evidence from Corbyn or anyone else that he can predict the weather,
especially not to the level of confidence he claims.
The bulk of his claimed accuracy is just confirmation bias - remembering the times when he's got something correct,
but forgetting all the times he's been wrong.
Thus he has slides confirming his prediction of heatwaves last month (August 2016), his prediction that July 2012 would be very wet,
the Great Storm of October 2013, and the exceptional cold of December 2010.
But they make no mention of his failures - that December 2011 would be exceptionally cold (it was a degree above average),
that May 2012 would be one of the coldest in 100 years (the month as a whole had average temperatures),
that February 2014 would be one of the driest in 100 years with drought developing in the South (it was one of the wettest)
that August 2014 would likely be the hottest on record (it was the only month that year to be below average).
Most of these he predicted with greater than 80% confidence, sometimes as much as 95%.
(All the above are forecasts for the UK.)
Even his claimed successes on closer examination are not always the spot-on successes he implies.
Take his forecast for July 2012 (slide 53).
The headline in the slide is The Apocalyptic deluges of July 2012 were well captured in WeatherAction DETAIL 45-75d ahead.
July was certainly wet, twice as much rainfall as average - but the forecast makes more specific claims.
Rainfall likely to be (90% confidence) wetter than July 2007 in England and Wales
and in the 12 wettest Julys in 247 years of records since 1786.
Wettest or in 4 wettest Julys in 100 years in SE England.
Rainfall for England and Wales July 2007 was 137.9mm, July 2012 was 120.7mm.
July 2012 was the 33rd wettest July in the England and Wales 247 year record.
July 2012 was the 13th wettest July in the 100 year SE England set.
What Piers Corbyn fails to do is provide any statistical analysis that his results are better than chance,
let alone the claimed 85% accuracy made from months in advance.
The closest thing to actual evidence is a single paper which he claims showed significant skill.
The problem is that this paper, by Denis Wheeler, failed to show any significant skill.
In particular it looked at a two year period of forecasts for storms in the UK,
and failed to show a statistically significant correlation between the forecasts and actual storms over winter months.
Cycles
In several slides Piers talks about cycles influencing the weather.
These cycles are claimed to come from the sun and the moon, but his evidence is scarce and the various cycles presented are contradictory.
The sun has an 11 year sun spot cycle and this is thought to have some influence on the climate,
but according to Piers it's the 22 year Hale cycle that matters more,
and this is modulated by a lunar cycle every 9.3 or 18.6 years. (Slide 17)
On slide 18 he explains how this leads to a 132 - 133 year cycle, corresponding to how these two cycles interact.
He explains that 6 x 22 = 132, and 7 x 19 = 133.
This at least makes some sense; if the sun and moon affect climate then there might be a corresponding beat when both are at there strongest.
Except he's already said the lunar cycle is 18.6 years, not 19, so there should be a peak every 130 years, not 133 as he claims.
This wouldn't be much of a problem if we were only talking about approximate lengths of time,
but Corbyn is claiming an exact period - or at least his only evidence is the fact that a short sequence of UK summer flooding
repeated a pattern exactly every 132 years.
But then he starts talking about an approximately 60 year cycle (slides 24 and 25),
which he also claims is governed by the same solar and lunar cycles.
You cannot fit a 60 year cycle into a 132 year cycle and claim that both are governed bhy the same two factors.
It also means that the 60 year cycle is not in step with the 11 or 22 year solar cycle.
If one 60 year cycle starts when the sun is at solar maximum, the next will start when the sun is at its minimum.
The only evidence for these cycles is a pair of graphs showing rises in temperature happening approximately 60 years apart -
except the trend lines appear to have been stuck on in order to confirm the 60 year cycle.
Even then there isn't much consistency.
In the graph showing USA temperatures for example, there is a claimed warming peak in 2002/3 (based on just 5 years of data),
but the previous peak happened 70 years earlier.
From slide 24 - Attributed to JD'Aleo Sept 2008.
Piers Corbyn explains how he gets a 60 year cycle from the solar and lunar cycles on slide 24 using this equation,
B - n - 2H,
where n is twice the inverse of the Lunar nodal Retreat rate, and H is half Z.
Z = 1 / Sunspot period = 1/11.1 /yr.
(Why he didn't use Z rather than 2H I don't know.)
Inverting B gives his ~58 year cycle.
There's no explanation as to why this equation makes any physical sense -
it looks like he simply played around with equations until he got the result he wanted.
Possibly the explanation is on slide 32 when he says:
Things are not always what they seem!
In Physics Drawing a diagram or writing an equation does not mean that you are showing something real
It's Cooling
It is one of Corbyn's main claims that we have entered a new mini-ice age, or a period of global cooling.
That is he doesn't just claim there was a pause, he's claiming there's been actual global cooling.
But obviously he provides no evidence to support the claim, and is very vague as to when he thinks this started.
So what we get is lots of strong assertions.
Sometimes these are predictions of imminent cooling Solar Activity Predicts Major COOLING (slide 36),
other times he's claiming there has been actual cooling -
Real temperatures are falling as CO2 warmist models rise (slide 47),
BUT Whatever they do, even with 'new' data the WORLD IS COOLING while CO2 still rises (slide 48),
The problem is all these claims are based on meaningless time scales producing insignificant cooling.
For example on slide 38 he claims there was cooling between 2007 and 2013.
Any cooling over that period would be indistinguishable from noise.
In any event he's wrong - all datasets including satellite data show a warming trend from 2007 to 2013.